With the launch of HomeView, Apple is venturing into a realm that has long been on their radar, but not directly addressed.
I'd like to point out something before getting to Apple's new product: nodes.
I first pointed out over a dozen years ago that all of us have essentially three technology nodes: home, in transit, and office. A true hardware+software company such as Apple needs to have solutions for all three.
If you think about it, Apple has dominated in transit: iPhone, CarPlay, iPad, iWatch. Staying connected, productive, and entertained while you're out and about (or just commuting) is easy in the Apple fiefdom. There isn't another company that covers in transit as well and in all three forms: hardware, software, and media.
The Mac and accessories have been the things that are supposed to cover Home and Business. But even there, it's the in transit part that Apple got right: MacBooks.
I'll give Tim Cook full marks for getting the in transit bits all pumped up, augmented, and supplemented. But Home and Business? Nope.
Let's start with the things Apple backed away from: printers and routers. I can see why Apple might have wanted to back away from the printer business, as they were OEMing hardware from others, not really in the ink business, and mostly just added cosmetics and software. Tough to justify in a world that keeps trying to move away from paper.
But routers? Discontinuing AirPort in all its variations, including the built-in backup of Time Capsule, was a huge mistake. Suffice it to say that if you want to dominate Home devices, it all starts with the communication hub. For Apple users, Apple did just that with AirPorts, as they were "very Apple" (simple to set up and maintain, highly functional, and easily extended into Time Machines and remote locations).
So here we now have Apple trying to elbow into Home devices again. Hmm. They don't control the communications (no AirPort), they have the most expensive streamer (Apple TV), they really only have one iMac and a mini built to handle sophisticated home computing, and now they have an appless square iPad called HomeView.
I've had a Google Nest Hub for some time, which is a similar concept to HomeView. It solves no problems for me. Indeed, as my Nest fire alarms and other devices all age out and aren't being replaced by Google, it's become a box that does nothing.
Apple is promising HomeView will do lots, but frankly, at the moment it also does next to nothing. Eventually, Apple says, you'll get doorbell, security device, thermostat, and other abilities from third parties at prices that China is so undercutting at the moment that I don't want to invest in Apple's Home.
As far as I can tell, HomeView isn't even the FaceTime device everyone was expecting. The square screen isn't optimal for video, and will compromise both vertical and horizontal videos. Moreover, the square FaceTime ability works best for other HomeViews, not so much for other Apple devices. Did Apple just invent the visual intercom? ;~)
What I think Apple has really created with HomeView is a speaker clock that can do some other stuff if you really need it to. But I always have my iWatch on and my iPhone with me, and they do a better job of "other stuff," even around the house.
Also missing in Apple's early marketing is an explicit discussion of Matter. The FAQ has "Which smart home accessories work with HomeView?" Apple being Apple, the answer is "Thousands of smart home accessories are compatible with HomeView and Apple Home products. Just look for the Works with Apple Home logo." Yep, Apple's trying to build another lock-in system on an open system. They list a huge number of devices ("See Accessories section" on this page), and I believe that's because they all use Matter, but not only is it unclear how those devices' controls are exposed, but how HomeView itself deals with them.
Nope, Apple ain't Home yet. It's a solid pass from me at this point, and I live in an Apple-dominated domicile and help my mom maintain another.
The no-app-but-Matter problem is buried in the footnotes on Apple's site:
- Requires a HomeKit- or Matter-enabled accessory. Smart home accessory sold separately.
- Video summaries and natural language search for HomeKit Secure Video camera recordings require setup using an Apple Intelligence–enabled iPhone or iPad and a subscription to an eligible iCloud+ plan. Requires a home hub such as HomeView, HomePod (2nd generation), HomePod mini, or Apple TV 4K with the latest operating system software.
- Setup requires Wi-Fi and iPhone or iPad with the latest software.