Like many living on the bleeding edge, I've been running a maxed out M2 Studio as my primary computer for a while. With Apple's most recent computer announcements, it was time to move to an M5 Max. Since software and storage requirements grow with each generation of programmers, I opted for more memory and SSD this time around (not that I felt I was taxing the older machine, but...you know, you can't add it later in Macdom).
While at order time Apple indicated it might be three months before I got my new machine, it actually arrived a week after the very first Studios started popping up.
A lot of you have asked about how you move from an older Mac to a newer one, so I thought I'd give you the big picture. But be aware, this isn't a ten minute process. Bring snacks and a comfortable chair, as you can be at this for a while.
- You need the right components. MacBooks are self contained, but if you're setting up an iMac, mini, or Studio, you need a mouse, keyboard, and in the case of the latter two, a display. I'll give you a tip: have a wired keyboard and mouse, it'll make your initial steps so much more pleasant and quick. You can set up Bluetooth (wireless) mouse and keyboard later once you're running. But if you don't know how to do Bluetooth peripheral setup from power on—or worse, you don't have current Apple wireless keyboard and mouse—you might find you get into a frustrating loop. One other thing you'll probably want: a Thunderbolt 5 cable that can run between your two machines (not required, but nice to have).
- Assemble your new computer nearby the one you'll be transferring from. Leave the older computer set up and working until you've verified that the new one has everything moved over and working. The more desk space you have, the better off you'll be during setup. You may be writing things down, mousing with two mice, and typing with two keyboards. That takes space.
- Hook up the keyboard, mouse, (and display) to your new computer and power it on. With wired choices, you go directly to telling the Mac your language, location, and other bits it'll want to know. If you use Bluetooth devices, you may have to get them connected first. One critical thing is to set the new Mac up clean. Apple will offer to do a transfer from your old Mac, but you don't want to get bogged down in that step. Choose Set up as new. Also, what's been happening with new machine introductions lately is that you won't get much further than giving the new Mac your Wi-Fi router ID and password when you'll be prompted to download a new version of macOS. Don't proceed without doing that, if prompted, because you'll just be asking for random trouble if you don't. The only issue here is that it takes time to download and install the update. But you brought snacks, right?
- Continue setting the new Mac up. One thing that is confusing is "Create a Mac Account." The critical word there is Mac, which is not Apple. You're not setting up a new Apple account (yet, that comes next), you're setting up the user folder and Admin account on the new Mac. I generally switch this around on my Macs so they don't all have the same user folder name. However, note that what you choose here is pretty permanent (it can be revised later, but at great pain). While it seems like it takes a long time to set up the Admin and sign into your Apple account, there's a lot going on in the background as the system sorts through all the plumbing you never see. I do a lot of Set up later choices as I work through all this, mostly because when we do transfer over from your old computer, most of that will be dealt with from the settings you were using, so why waste the time at this stage. Eventually you'll get to the Welcome message. Time for another snack.
- Do some basic work on the (stripped) computer. That's right, once you get through the Set up as new bits, it's time to test drive what you've got. This is especially important if the new computer also means moving to a new version of macOS. Really, do a test drive of the basic stripped down system without all your apps and data. See what's actually there by default. I like to do at least one Restart at this point, to make sure that the system comes right back up to where I expect it to and that it is asking for my password. At some point you'll get a notification along the lines of See what's new in macOS 27. Take the tour.
- Do an overnight burn-in. Electronic devices tend to fail within the first few hours of being used if they're going to fail electronically. I don't want to waste any more time setting up the new machine until I know that it can keep running overnight. It's going to be very very very very rare that this step actually triggers anything worth noting, let alone complete failure. I tend to leave the new Mac running Apple Music (with the sound turned off), but anything that is doing regular CPU/memory tasks should be fine.
- Perform a migration. It's time to move everything over to the new Mac from your old one. On both computers, open Applications > Utilities > Migration Assistant and follow the directions. At one point in the process you'll be asked whether to replace the user on the new Mac, and the answer to that should be yes. However, note there's another option under that: you don't need to copy the old user, as you really did nothing other than play under that user account. Some folk say don't use Migration Assistant for moving applications, just install them from scratch. This is partly an anti-Adobe stance, as it was mostly Adobe that left cruft behind when they were updating apps, but I don't see any real value in avoiding applications being moved by Migration Assistant. Note that once you finally start the migration on both machines, you'll be logged out of your old computer and both machines will be unavailable for use until the migration has completed. This can take a long, long time depending upon how much is on that older Mac that you want brought over. Long time as in hours. This is one reason why some prefer to do a migration over an Ethernet connection or even a Thunderbolt 5 connection rather than Wi-Fi. For large migrations, you probably want to have them done overnight.
- Shut down both machines and re-cable. If you have peripherals hooked up to your old machine, detach them, get your old machine out of the way, put your new machine where the old machine was, and re-attach everything. This is a great time to do cable-rationalizing. If we're talking desktop computer that's been used for a long time, there's probably a cable warren back there. Take your time and rationalize every connection. Remember, Thunderbolt can daisy-chain. I have three daisy-chains coming off my Studio, which technically support ten "drives." You want a balanced load. So one chain has two StudioStacks and a CFExpress reader on it. Another chain goes to my LaCie Bigs. And the last goes to a Pegasus RAID and a few oddball things plugged into it. While you're at it, dust and clean as you make these swaps.
- Now comes the sign-in fun. Almost certainly there are going to be sign-ins. Apple will ask you to sign in. Microsoft will ask you to sign in (if you're using any of their apps). Everyone's going to ask you to sign in. So it pays to step through every application you have installed and see what happens when you launch it. Best case: nothing, you're good to go. Worst case, not only do you need to sign in, but the app uses some macOS extensions or features (e.g. Full Disk Access) that need to be approved. Set aside your morning for this fun little tour. Hope you still have some snacks left.
- You're not done. You'll want to check that your backups (including Time Machine) still work. This is a good time to perform a full Virus scan, check your Firewall settings, and double-check that you've set your security permissions correctly. You'll also want to go to the App Store and make sure any necessary updates are applied (they may simply be "pending" at this point).
- Recycle your old Mac. You have two basic choices for your old Mac: recycle it or repurpose it (either as a pass-me-down or selling). If you're just going to use it as another Mac, you're probably done. However, before you sell or pass your Mac on to others you need to remove your account from the old Mac and get that machine back to its "original" state (original is in quotes because it may now have an upgraded macOS). To do that reset to original state, use System Settings > General > Transfer or Reset > Erase All Content and Settings (this is for macOS Monterey or later; earlier macOS versions have different instructions).
If you've been paying attention, it's taken you over two days to get all this swapping done (overnight burn-in and overnight migration). This is one reason why updating machines is not a trivial task you want to do every time Apple creates a new M chip. Let your machine(s) work through two or better yet a few generations of Apple's updating before you get out your wallet.
This is also why you should buy a Mac that's a bit (or more) beyond your current needs. That will allow you to skip some generations and avoid this update hassle. So instead of buying the minimal 16GB/512GB floor, opt for some more RAM, a bigger SSD, and perhaps some more CPU/GPU power.
Example: Instead of a Mac mini M6 with 16GB/512GB (US$999), consider a 32GB/1TB (US$1649). Yes, that's US$650 more, but if it helps you extend its lifespan by a couple of years, it would be money well spent.